In recent years there has been a huge push to encourage and keep children reading. With the increase in accessibility to video games and social media, the youth of today are finding other ways to keep themselves entertained and focusing less on libraries and traditional books. Now I am in no way saying that social media and video games do not have their own benefits or ways of teaching children, however I feel as if the tradition of sitting down with a good book and getting lost in the world of words may be slowly becoming a thing of the past for many of todays youth.
Taking this into consideration it baffles me that now we seem to be constantly combatting libraries or schools that wish to ban certain young adult books!
The following website provides a comprehensive list of young adult novels that have at one point or another been banned by schools and libraries.
http://popcrush.com/young-adult-banned-books/
Now whilst it is understandable that not all schools wish to use certain young adult books in their curriculum, it is hard to believe that they are being banned for general reading purposes. I even know of schools that have not only excluded certain books from their curriculum and libraries, but have also banned students from bringing these books to school for them to read during their lunch breaks! This raises a few problems for me. First of all, I personally believe that parents should have the ultimate say on what their children are exposed to, whether this is television, books, movies etc. If a school is contradicting the parent’s decisions, what message is this sending our kids?
Secondly, libraries have the privilege of being able to provide knowledge, not censor knowledge. If information is kept from the public due to libraries sorting it first, can we therefore say that libraries are truly a place to gather all types of knowledge? While some of these young adult novels do have challenging themes within them, they are all written because the youth of today are able to relate with them in some way or another. It is one thing for a parent or a teacher to say that they do not wish for their students to be exposed to the issues raised within some of these novels, but the reality is that they already are! When students gather knowledge about challenging youth issues from books, they develop an awareness and understanding of the real world and can grow into a well-informed and active citizen. Schools in particular have an amazing ability to provide students with knowledge and expose them to issues in a safe and supportive environment, where questions can be answered.
Mass provides a list of 10 young adult books which have been banned by schools and libraries in recent times. Some of the more popular books on the list included The Giver, Looking for Alaska, the Gossip Girl series, and of particular interest The Hunger Games by Suzanna Collins. The Hunger Games series has been challenged and banned on several occasions by different schools and libraries due to the use of strong violence and anti family themes. In contradiction to these bans in educational settings Dail and Giles go into considerable detail when discussing the positive impact of The Hunger Games in an educational setting. They believe that “Collin’s novel raises many questions about society and our reality television culture, and when implemented purposefully in the classroom, can lead students to critically examine the ways in which reality television shows are mediated experiences for the participants and the viewers” (2012).
When considering the educational benefits and potential for learning when reading these young adult novels, is it perhaps more important to educate our youth on these issues, rather than banning the novels which act as vessel for learning.
References
Dail, J., & Giles, T. (2012), The Hunger Games and Little Brother Come to Life of Voice Thread: Helping Students Respond Visually to Young Adult Literature. The ALAN Review, 6-11.
Mass, E. (2014). 10 Young Adult Books That Have Been Banned. http://popcrush.com/young-adult-banned-books